Green tea history: the monks noticed it first

The reason tea traveled with Buddhist monasteries reads like a startlingly exact description of what modern attention trials measure.

What the monasteries were after

Buddhist monastic life is tangled up with how tea moved across East Asia, and the reason given for it is the part worth pausing on. Tea kept monks awake through long stretches of seated meditation without the restlessness that would have ruined the sitting.

Treat that as a description of a drug effect and it is oddly precise. Not stimulation and not sedation. Alert but not agitated — which is close to a summary of what the L-theanine and caffeine literature now reports. Green tea traditional use, in other words, was functional long before it was ceremonial.

No mechanism was available to them and no compound could be isolated. They observed something, wrote it down, and the observation held for twelve hundred years before chemistry could account for it. That is the green tea history worth knowing.

The compound behind the description

Almost nothing else people eat contains L-theanine; as amino acids go it is close to unique to the tea plant. Set it beside the modest caffeine that tea leaf carries anyway and the pair does something neither does separately.

On its own, caffeine lifts alertness and hands back jitter and a slump. On its own, theanine is mild. Tested together on attention-switching tasks, the pairing beat each single compound inside a couple of hours — Haskell's crossover study from 2008 being the reference people cite.

Alert without agitation. The monks were describing a real pharmacological event in the only words they had. The modern account is here.

Shade, grown for flavour

A second accident sits in how the leaf is cultivated.

The plant makes L-theanine down in the root and sends it upward; once it reaches the leaf, sunlight turns a portion of it into catechins. Keep the light off and less of that conversion happens, so more theanine stays theanine.

Japanese growers have shaded bushes for weeks ahead of picking for centuries, and the motive was taste — theanine reads as sweet and savoury on the palate, and shade-grown leaf commands a premium for it. Gyokuro and matcha are what the method produces.

So a technique adopted purely for flavour concentrates the compound with the best attention data behind it. Once again, nobody involved could have said why. Matcha L-theanine content is a by-product of chasing a better cup.

The heat step that makes it green

One plant, Camellia sinensis, gives both green and black tea. Processing is the only thing separating them: green leaf meets heat very soon after picking — steam in Japan, a hot pan in China — and that heat stops the enzymatic oxidation which would otherwise darken it.

Stopping the oxidation is what keeps the catechins intact, EGCG among them, and the catechins are what most of the antioxidant research concerns. Another choice made for color and taste with a chemical result nobody was aiming at.

From the cup to a capsule

Tradition runs out at this point, so here is the practical side. How to take green tea extract depends mostly on what else is in the capsule, and green tea extract dosage only means anything read next to the form:

  • Inside a formula. A modest extract, bringing EGCG, theanine and a little naturally occurring caffeine along together — sold today as green tea extract for focus.
  • Early in the day. That caffeine total sits under a cup of coffee, but it is real, and a late capsule can show up in your sleep.
  • On its own. Theanine is sold separately at 100–200 mg and often taken with coffee on purpose — a different proposition from a formula capsule.
  • One caution. Very high doses of concentrated extract have been linked to rare liver trouble in a small number of reports, which argues for modest amounts in a mixture.

Quick answers

Does matcha have more theanine?

Yes. Leaf grown under shade, matcha and gyokuro included, measures higher, because the sunlight the plant misses is the sunlight that would have turned theanine into catechins.

Why not just brew a cup?

You can, and you will get catechins, caffeine and theanine. What you will not get is a known amount: leaf, water temperature and brewing time move the numbers around a great deal, which is the one thing a standardised extract fixes.

What does L-theanine do on its own?

Very little that announces itself. Its reputation comes from the company it keeps: with a small amount of caffeine, attention-switching has been measured to improve inside about two hours.

Keep reading